5 Signs You're Ready to Retire Early (Even If You're Terrified)

The spreadsheet says you're ready.

You've run the numbers a dozen times. Different scenarios. Conservative projections. Market crashes. Healthcare costs. That nagging "what if" about inflation. The math checks out every time.

So why does hitting "submit" on your retirement paperwork feel like stepping off a cliff?

Here's what nobody tells you about early retirement: Financial readiness and psychological readiness are not the same thing.

According to research from the Employee Benefit Research Institute, nearly 40% of people who are financially capable of retiring early delay for 2-5 years—not because of money, but because of fear.

Fear of losing identity. Fear of being bored. Fear of making a mistake. Fear of... well, freedom itself.

But here's the twist: Sometimes that fear is actually a sign you're MORE ready than you think.

The Retirement Readiness Paradox

Jennifer was 53 when she first ran her retirement numbers. Former director at a Fortune 500 company. Solid investments. No debt. The financial advisor gave her the green light.

She waited four more years.

"I kept thinking I needed just one more promotion, one more year of savings, one more... something," she told me. "I was 57 before I realized I wasn't waiting for financial security. I was waiting for permission. Or maybe courage."

Jennifer's story isn't unusual. Stanford University researchers studying retirement transitions found that people who are most thoughtful about retirement—who worry about it, plan for it, question their readiness—often adapt better than those who leap without reflection.

The anxiety isn't a red flag. It's evidence you're taking it seriously.

So how do you know if you're ready? Not financially ready (talk to your advisor about that), but actually, genuinely, psychologically ready to trade your desk for a deck chair?

Here are five signs—some unexpected—that you're closer than you think.

1) You're Fantasizing About Regular Tuesdays, Not Just Exotic Vacations

When most people think about retirement, they picture beaches, golf courses, and European river cruises. The highlight reel.

But if you're truly ready, you'll notice your retirement fantasies have gotten more mundane.

You're not just dreaming about two weeks in Tuscany. You're imagining a Tuesday morning where you:

• Drink coffee slowly, reading the entire newspaper
• Take a mid-morning yoga class (not the 6am one you rush to before work)
• Spend three hours working on a hobby project with zero interruptions
• Have lunch with a friend who's also available on a Tuesday

Why this matters: According to Stanford Center on Longevity research, people who can envision the ordinary rhythms of retirement (not just the extraordinary moments) have a clearer sense of what will actually fill their days. That specificity is crucial.

The vacations will happen. But it's the regular Tuesdays that define retirement. If you can imagine what a satisfying Tuesday looks like—and you want THAT more than your current work—you're psychologically ready.

2) You're Mourning Your Career While Still In It

This one sounds contradictory, but stay with me.

If you're feeling nostalgic about your career—thinking about the "good old days" when work was exciting, when you felt energized by Monday mornings—while you're still working, that's actually a readiness signal.

You're not mourning the job itself. You're mourning what it used to mean to you.

American Psychological Association research on career transitions identifies this as "anticipatory grief"—processing the loss of something before it's gone. It's a psychological preparation mechanism.

Signs you're experiencing anticipatory grief:

• You catch yourself saying "I used to love this part of my job" more than "I love this"
• You're reminiscing about past projects but dragging your feet on current ones
• You feel guilty that you're not as engaged as you once were
• You're mentally cataloging your career accomplishments, as if writing your own highlight reel

Why this matters: You're already doing the emotional work of separation. Your brain is creating distance, preparing you for the transition. Fighting this—forcing enthusiasm you don't feel—just prolongs the inevitable.

3) The "What's the Point?" Question Surfaces More Often

Not in a depressed, nihilistic way. In a genuinely curious way.

You're sitting in your fifth meeting of the day about the Q4 strategy, and a voice in your head whispers: "Does this actually matter?"

You're reviewing the same kind of report you've reviewed 200 times before, and you think: "Who will remember this next year? Will I?"

This isn't burnout (though it might feel similar). Harvard's Study of Adult Development found that this existential questioning in high-performers often signals that someone has outgrown their role—not failed at it.

You're not questioning whether the work is important to the company. You're questioning whether it's important to you anymore. Whether trading your time for this specific impact still feels like a fair exchange.

4) You're Already Practicing "Retirement Behaviors"

Without necessarily planning it, you've started doing small things that mirror retirement life:

• Taking all your vacation days (maybe for the first time in decades)
• Declining optional evening work events
• Developing or deepening hobbies that have nothing to do with career advancement
• Strengthening friendships outside of work
• Saying "no" to projects that would have excited you three years ago
• Spending weekends doing activities you wish you could do more often

These aren't signs of disengagement. They're rehearsals.

According to MIT AgeLab research, people who gradually shift their time allocation toward non-work activities in the 2-3 years before retirement report smoother transitions. Your brain is already testing the waters.

The litmus test: When you take a week off, do you dread going back? Or does it feel neutral—like, "Well, I guess I'll go back for now"? That "for now" is telling. You're already mentally one foot out the door.

5) You're Asking Different Questions Than You Used To

Five years ago, your questions were about career trajectory:

• "How do I get to the next level?"
• "What skills do I need to develop?"
• "Should I take this promotion?"

Now your questions have shifted:

• "How do I want to spend my time?"
• "What legacy do I want to leave?"
• "What would I do if I had complete freedom?"
• "What matters to me beyond professional achievement?"

This shift from achievement-focused questions to meaning-focused questions is one of the most reliable readiness indicators.

National Institute on Aging research on successful aging identifies this as a cognitive transition that typically happens 18-36 months before someone is psychologically ready to retire. Your value system is recalibrating.

You're no longer asking "Am I successful?" You're asking "Am I fulfilled?"

Those are fundamentally different questions. And once you start asking the second one, the first one loses its power over you.

What About the Fear?

Here's the part that might surprise you: All five signs can coexist with legitimate fear.

You can be psychologically ready AND terrified.

Rachel, who retired at 51, described it perfectly: "It felt like standing at the edge of a pool. I knew how to swim. I wanted to swim. The water looked perfect. But that moment before you jump? Pure terror."

Fear doesn't mean you're not ready. It means you're aware of what you're about to do.

AARP research on retirement transitions found that 73% of people who successfully transitioned to early retirement reported significant anxiety in the months before leaving. The difference? They jumped anyway—because they recognized the difference between fear and unreadiness.

Fear says: "This is a big change."
Unreadiness says: "I have no idea what I'm doing."

If you can answer basic questions—What will I do with my time? Who will I spend it with? What gives me purpose beyond work?—even if the answers aren't perfect, you're ready enough.

Perfection isn't the goal. Direction is.

The One Question That Tells You Everything

Want a single question that cuts through all the noise?

Here it is:

Not "should I?" Not "is it smart?" Not "what will people think?"

Just: Would I?

If your gut answer is "Yes, absolutely"—even if it's immediately followed by "But..." and a list of fears—you're ready.

If your gut answer is "I don't know" or "Not yet," honor that. There's no prize for retiring early if you're not ready. The spreadsheet can say yes, but you need to feel it too.

What Comes After the Decision?

So you've read these five signs. Maybe you recognized yourself in all of them. Maybe just a few.

If you're nodding along thinking, "This is me. I think I'm ready. Now what?"—that's a whole different conversation.

Because deciding you're ready and actually making the transition are two very different things.

The psychological shift from career professional to early retiree is one of the most significant identity transitions you'll ever navigate. There's the identity question (who am I without my business card?), the structure question (what do I do with completely unscheduled days?), the social question (how do I build community outside of work?), and a dozen other challenges nobody warned you about.

But here's the good news: These transitions are completely navigable. You're not the first person to walk this path. Research from Harvard, Stanford, and dozens of other institutions has mapped out what works (and what doesn't) for successful retirement transitions.

Join the Conversation

Which of these five signs resonated most with you? Are you still gathering courage, or have you already made the leap?

• Website: www.casualmondayspodcast.com
• Instagram: @casualmondayspodcast
• YouTube: Casual Mondays Podcast

Trade in your suit for sandals and your desk for a deck chair. Welcome to Casual Mondays.